Skip to main content

An Indonesian firm has appealed a landmark court ruling that struck down a contract it had to provide water services in Jakarta, in a case likely to be closely watched as a yardstick of the country's investor friendliness.

Two companies, Indonesia's PT Aetra Air Jakarta and PT PAM Lyonnaise Jaya (Palyja), part of France's Suez Environnement, secured contracts with a company owned by the Jakarta government in the late 1990s.

But the Central Jakarta district court last month ruled in favor of a citizen's group which claimed the companies failed to provide sufficient clean water and annulled the contracts.

"We feel that we have positively helped the stakeholders of this agreement and what was decided at the court was not in accordance with what we had already done," Pratama S. Adi, Aetra's corporate secretary, said of the appeal.

Palyja also said last week it plans to appeal the ruling.

The case represents the first time an Indonesian court has, at the instigation of a number of citizens, decided to invalidate an agreement between a government firm and a private party, Indonesian law firm Hadiputranto, Hadinoto & Partners said in a letter to clients.

"While there is still hope that the higher level courts will rectify the situation, the Central Jakarta District Court's decision is a blow to the government's effort to assure private investors that Indonesia has a solid investment climate underpinning its infrastructure sectors," the letter said.

Fitch Ratings said on Thursday it does not see any immediate refinancing risks for Aetra, but noted uncertainties surrounding the treatment of Aetra's assets and liabilities if the court decision is upheld.

Related Articles

Q&A with Edwin Northover, Debevoise & Plimpton LLP

Debevoise & Plimpton LLP won the Insurance Law Firm of the Year award at the ALB Hong Kong Law Awards 2024, apart from being the sponsor of the Insurance In-House Team of the Year award. Edwin Northover, Asia-based corporate partner and head of the firm’s financial institutions and corporate practices in Asia, talks about the firm's recent achievements, trends in the insurance industry, and future outlook for insurance law in Hong Kong.

Kramer Levin and Herbert Smith Freehills plan latest law firm mega-merger

by Reuters |

U.S. law firm Kramer Levin Naftalis & Frankel and global legal giant Herbert Smith Freehills are planning to merge to create a firm with more than 2,700 lawyers, according to a joint statement on Monday.

Tokyo International makes Singapore debut with SE Asia in its sights

by Sarah Wong |

Japanese boutique Tokyo International Law Office (TKI) is set to establish its first overseas outpost with the opening of a Singapore office in January 2025, marking a significant milestone in the rapidly expanding firm's global strategy.